Created in collaboration with Neil Diamond himself, this the story of a kid from Brooklyn who became a chartbusting, show-stopping American rock icon – with 140 million albums sold, a catalogue of classics like ‘Cracklin’ Rosie’, ‘Forever in Blue Jeans’ and ‘Sweet Caroline’; an induction into the Songwriters and Rock and Roll Halls of Fame; a Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award and sold-out concerts around the world. But this show starts on a sombre note. An elderly and grumpy Diamond (Terence Crawford) sits on one side of the stage across from a psychologist (Monica Sayers), who is questioning him on his malaise. Why is he there at all? Because his family says he’s hard to get along with. Our hero is about to call it quits and leave, but a songbook is produced by the doctor… and a younger Neil (Will Swenson) hits the stage (and the music) with a full on version of ‘America’ and the ‘beautiful noise’ has begun. Big time!
It’s a clever way to tell Diamond’s story and this is an energy-filled musical memoir set to the songs that defined his career but one that doesn’t shy away from what appear to have been, at times, crippling insecurity, loneliness and one very bad decision.
Ellie Greenwich (played by Hannah Fredericksen), whom Diamond met in 1965 looms large. She enabled his career, first as a songwriter for others (‘I’m a Believer’ and ‘Red, Red Wine’) and then as a performer with his first charting single ‘Solitary Man’. This was quickly followed by the even more successful ‘Cherry, Cherry.’
Diamond’s voice, described in the show as ‘gravel wrapped in velvet’, is channelled by Swenson, who comes to the role from shows in Melbourne and before that from Boston in the US, where he performed as Neil in the musical’s premiere in 2022. Safe to say Swenson knows how to play, and sing, the role.
The young now successful Diamond’s first marriage to Jaye (Alana Tranter) soon flounders, exacerbated by his workload and touring schedule. His next marriage, to Marcia Murphey (Ashleigh Rubenach), lasts longer – 25 years in fact. Meanwhile, Diamond has signed up to Bang Records. The friction between Diamond, this record company (its logo is a gun) and Mob figures is dramatised here alongside Bang’s efforts to keep Diamond in his contract. In what is portrayed as an extremely lucky break, he released ‘Sweet Caroline’ after extracting himself. That number, as you would expect, was rousing, well done and very well received. It is the closing song of Act 1.
In Act 2, which ups the pace, we have Diamond in his Hot August Night persona (complete with an almost Princess Di 80s haircut) and Swenson belting out the hits that made the singer such a superstar everywhere. Diamond was a bigger box-office draw than Elvis. In this country alone, he toured seven times, from the landmark Thank You Australia tour in 1976 through to 2015. That 1972 live album Hot August Night spent 29 weeks at number one here and 65 weeks on the chart, making it the third-longest charting album of its era in Australian music history.
As for Diamond’s personal life, songs such as ‘Song Sung Blue’, ‘Love on the Rocks’, ‘You Don’t Bring Me Flowers” and ‘Brother Love’s Travelling Salvation Show’, still bring the house down but give audiences extra nuance as they show us what might have been going on in Diamond’s head when he wrote them.
All the hits are here – the rendition of ‘Crunchy Granola Suite’ was brilliant, exhausting to watch almost! Diamond fans will not be disappointed.
Terence Crawford as the older Neil, reflecting on his life and struggling to come to terms with himself, is very good indeed. His role is largely spoken, but his rendition of ‘I Am… I Said’ is strong and powerful, and especially evocative. It is the climax of the show and a defining moment in the proceedings.
A Beautiful Noise is just what is says it is, and everything fans will want from a high-voltage musical, but the ‘therapy’ comments that pepper the songwriting processes provide a little nuance about the man behind the hits. It honours a spectacular career. And his songs will stay in your head for days to come!
A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond runs at the Lyric Theatre, Pyrmont, until February 2027
From $69- $335, plus transaction fees
www.theneildiamondmusical.com.au
